Do you want the truth if you can sing or not? Post up.

This topic is listed in Singing & Songwriting Tips. It has been viewed 2,428 times and 71 replies have been made.

  Next >>
socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Edited post by socomicefox

Have not done this in a while and I know alot of ppl like to know the truth rather or not they can sing and I enjoyed doing this the last time as the singers I critiqued went from awful to great singers.. So post up I will give you the truth. If you post me trash I will tell you your song is trash. So bring me a song to listen to that I will enjoy. There is no favoritism in my critiques if your a good singer I will tell you. If you are a singer that cant sing your way out of a bucket I will tell you. Sing a song on Singsnap and post the link to your song.

If you feel you cant sing and cant handle true critique do not post. No drama. Just cause if I say you cant sing. Im no pro. I can sing somewhat. Im just telling you my thoughts on your singing.

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Edited reply by socomicefox

Cruel
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/watchandlisten/play/c1ac90ceb

Trip & fall
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/watchandlisten/play/bebabfeff

Thanks2Become1

Cruel- First off 2become1 when I listen to a singer I like to hear their voice not mixers/machines. With that said though see your recording of this song was really good. I loved the way you got creative in this song with the harmony. You did stay on pitch most the song so good job there and your emotion was good you 100% was into this song I could tell. This was a great song choice for you. I never heard this song before but your vocals on this was nice. I still have this song playing in my head as I type this.

Trip&Fall- You sing this song outstanding and this is why I flagged you. The way you did sing this song this was a pefect song choice. You did not go off pitch. You got creative again with the effects but you made this recording sound damn good! Your timing in this fast pace song was really good. You had great control in this song. 10/10. This was outstanding.

Again I heard you being creative in your recordings from what I can tell? Hell yea you can sing its why I flagged you. Keep singing 2become1. You introduced me to 2 songs today I never heard before. The wonderful world of music is great. Hella good job on your songs. From what I can tell you have good vocals and you are creative when you sing and know how to make your recordings sound very professional. Great job.

2Become1

Reply by 2Become1

Cruel
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/watchandlisten/play/c1ac90ceb

Trip & fall
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/watchandlisten/play/bebabfeff

Thanks2Become1

Cruel- First off 2become1 when I listen to a singer I like to hear their voice not mixers/machines. With that said though see your recording of this song was really good. I loved the way you got creative in this song with the harmony. You did stay on pitch most the song so good job there and your emotion was good you 100% was into this song I could tell. This was a great song choice for you. I never heard this song before but your vocals on this was nice. I still have this song playing in my head as I type this.

Trip&Fall- You sing this song outstanding and this is why I flagged you. The way you did sing this song this was a pefect song choice. You did not go off pitch. You got creative again with the effects but you made this recording sound damn good! Your timing in this fast pace song was really good. You had great control in this song. 10/10. This was outstanding.

Again I heard you being creative in your recordings from what I can tell? Hell yea you can sing its why I flagged you. Keep singing 2become1. You introduced me to 2 songs today I never heard before. The wonderful world of music is great. Hella good job on your songs. From what I can tell you have good vocals and you are creative when you sing and know how to make your recordings sound very professional. Great job.socomicefox

They are songs i wrote myself, thankyou for listening and feedback

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Reply by socomicefox

Halo
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/b9708efb1

Waterfalls
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/b8a49f059

Thank you!SoloSongstress

Halo- Alright solosongstress on this song you did go flat in some parts. But your emotion in this sing was 10/10. I could tell you was singing this song to someone. I was singing along with ya. Your timing in this song was great. Overall this was actually a good sing. I like how you did this song.

Waterfalls- This right here is a tough song to sing. One of my favorite songs by TLC. Alright so you did go flat in part of the song but ya know what you actually picked up and kept this song your way and kept it just as good as the original. You did lack emotion into this song until the rap part then you impressed me with the skill of rapping! Your timing was perfect I felt during the sing you did rush in some parts but that rap part made me flag you. And also to mention your vocals are great! I heard you and not effects! Perfect song choice for your voice!

Can you sing? Hell yea and you can rap! You are talented in singing and rapping. Good job Solosongstress!

SoloSongstressLEVEL 102

Reply by SoloSongstressGOLD

Thanks so much for taking the time to listen to and critique my performances!

PetesecretLEVEL 84

Reply by PetesecretGOLD

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Edited reply by socomicefox

keeper of the stars
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/b198a5207

music of the night
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/b6603521f

ty sirPETESECRET1

Keeper of the stars- Alright PETESECRET`1 this song I have to ask was you drunk singing this? You have a odd voice your vocals are alright your not tone deaf but close to it I think. I liked how you did this song to be honest. You was really getting into it. Was entertaining for sure. Your timing in this song was not great but not horrible. You have a great vibrato.

music of the night- Your vocals fit well in this song. The vibrato really helped. You can tell tried your best to show emotion in this song. To be honest this was a really boring sing from start to finish but I think this song fits your voice more than keeper of the stars did. There was one part in music of the night where you tried to hit the high notes and I asked myself what the hell am I listening to right now.

So can you sing? I mean your not the best I ever heard and your for sure not the worst I ever heard. I mean I have heard worse. In my opinion you have a good vibrato. You for sure sing with heart. Your not tone def but I think you might be close to it. Yea I would say you can sing somewhat.

I would say Petesecret1 work on that timing and work on staying on pitch in songs and sing like you want to sing sing from your heart and go 100% everytime and nothing less. Best of luck to you Petesecret1. I would also like to add thank you for your hard work at Singsnap as Singsnap staff.

flatduckLEVEL 44

Reply by flatduckGOLD

cheqerLEVEL 58

Reply by cheqerGOLD

Love Is On The Way-Saigon Kick
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/b3ae0e879

Straight Up-Paula Abdul
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c2685e625

I respectfully place my head upon your chopping block...

PetesecretLEVEL 84

Reply by PetesecretGOLD

ok ty soco ,,,I have a strong Lancashire accent ,,I don't drink .
ty for your comments;
never consider myself a great singer ,,so for you too portray me as average is ok by me,
its all for fun ,,
yes I love being admin in the singing chat room

jaderottie63LEVEL 80

Reply by jaderottie63GOLD

oooh fun fun I LOVE Honesty

jaderottie63LEVEL 80

Edited reply by jaderottie63GOLD

OK here we go

jaderottie63
L.O.V.E ~ Al Green
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/ba77d349f

Songbird35LEVEL 59

Edited reply by Songbird35GOLD

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Reply by socomicefox

http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c5bc5b645

somethig to get you laughingflatduck

Alright flatduck!

C'est beau la vie- From what I can tell the last time I heard you your vocals got a litte bit better you still was off in alot of parts of the song but you did get a tiny bit better! You was off pitch in this song alot though again. First time I ever heard this song. You did sing this with good emotion I was not that bored though. To be honest this was a good song choice fit your voice good. I looked up the meaning of C'est beau la vie. Beautiful song.

Can you sing? Nah not really but keep singing long as you have fun.

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Reply by socomicefox

Love Is On The Way-Saigon Kick
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/b3ae0e879

Straight Up-Paula Abdul
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c2685e625

I respectfully place my head upon your chopping block... cheqer

Hi Cheqer

Love is on the way- Your vocals on this song here was actually really good. This song fit your voice. Your timing was nice! I could tell for sure you was singing this song from the heart and I saw that this was a contest song and I do hope you placed in the contest. This was a great sing. You did go off pitch in some parts but made up for it quick. Nothing negative I can say about this song as this song fit your voice good! This song is what made me flag you.

Straight up- One of my favorite Paula Abul songs was just absolutely ruined. This was terrifying. Vocals was kinda decent but this song was boring it didnt fit you at all. I could tell you was having fun but still this was absolutely horrible. Timing was good but. Nahhh this song was not good for you to sing.

Can you sing? Yea you can sing when you pick the right songs. You actually have great vocals.

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Edited reply by socomicefox

OK here we go

jaderottie63
L.O.V.E ~ Al Green
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/ba77d349fjaderottie63

Jaderottie63-

L.O.V.E- I like how you did this sing. I actually like Al green. Your voice is good for rock. Your voice does not actually fit this song but you got creative on this song and that it is good. Your vocals was off at some parts but you for sure was getting into this song I can tell you like this song. This was not a amazing sing but you had fun you brought a excellent attitude to this song thats for sure and from what I can tell your timing in this song was great. You took a r&b song and rocked out on it. Good job.

Can you sing? I have heard you sing other stuff before for sure you can sing. You are a great singer. Now on this song L.O.V.E I would not call this the best song choice for you.

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Reply by socomicefox

God Only Knows
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/ca9894a7d

One for my Baby
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c17b94bd7Songbird35

Songbird35-

God Only Knows- This was a depressing song. I never heard it before till now. But this sing was so good by you. I thought to myself how am I not bored on this sing? But I could feel you was singing this from the heart. Your vocals on this sing was on pitch! You did very good this sing and actually was nice to listen to this sing. You have a unique voice but very talented! I would say this was a good song choice.

One for my baby- This right here I knew you was about to ace. Your vocals was great. You have a very calm voice. You did sing this song from the heart I felt like I was listening at a club to a person sing a song. This was a beautiful sing by you songbird well done!

Can you sing? Hell yes you can sing. You have a great voice. Very talented unique voice. At some parts I asked myself how am I not bored of this sing but could never figure out why. You actually are a great singer songbird35. Thank you for the songs.

cheqerLEVEL 58

Reply by cheqerGOLD

Thank you! I've taken your opinions, advice and critique to heart.
Thanks!

flatduckLEVEL 44

Reply by flatduckGOLD

http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c5bc5b645

somethig to get you laughingflatduck

Alright flatduck!

C'est beau la vie- From what I can tell the last time I heard you your vocals got a litte bit better you still was off in alot of parts of the song but you did get a tiny bit better! You was off pitch in this song alot though again. First time I ever heard this song. You did sing this with good emotion I was not that bored though. To be honest this was a good song choice fit your voice good. I looked up the meaning of C'est beau la vie. Beautiful song.

Can you sing? Nah not really but keep singing long as you have fun.socomicefox

i m ok as long as you had fun saying your opinion , lol i made somebody happy

can you really judge with a good opinion ? nah not really but as long have you have fun doing it

jaderottie63LEVEL 80

Reply by jaderottie63GOLD

Thank you for the honest critique I Love it I always thought
that this was my type of Music humm........ lol Melanie

Songbird35LEVEL 59

Reply by Songbird35GOLD

Thank you for your kind comments I love to sing and gav e up as a professional singer to marry and raise a family
Now single and singing again thanks again x

nitasue2012LEVEL 52

Reply by nitasue2012GOLD

Merle Haggard

"The bottle let me down"
"
Emmylou Harris

" Two more bottles of wine"

Elvis Presley

"In The Garden

nitasue2012LEVEL 52

Reply by nitasue2012GOLD

what did I do wrong that you all can see the link to these songs?

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Reply by socomicefox

Merle Haggard

"The bottle let me down"
"
Emmylou Harris

" Two more bottles of wine"

Elvis Presley

"In The Gardennitasue2012

The bottle let me down- Love how you did this sing here. You did go flat in some parts of this song. I say you was getting into this song. I enjoyed it.

Two more bottles of wine- Vocals is decent. You are feeling this song I can tell. Your timing in was off in many parts of this song. This was a alright sing. I liked it.

In the garden- Very beautiful. You got me on this one nitasue I am feeling this sing from you. This was so good from start to end. I have no complaints on this song. You sing this from the heart and it was a honor to listen to this sing. Your mother would be very proud of this great sing you did.

Can you sing? During your In the garden sing. I can tell you sing that from the heart. You got me tearing up as I listen to that and I dont listent to that kinda music much but I 100% felt a singer who was singing from the heart. Yes you can sing for sure. A honor to listen to you nitasue2012.

wayne1956LEVEL 82

Reply by wayne1956GOLD

"Ace in the Hole" - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/bc922b1eb
"Old Flames" - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c18c8fb4b
"Devil Woman" - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/ae7c1d6f3

Hi,
I would appreciate your opinion!

Regards,
Wayne

WallyGBLEVEL 58

Reply by WallyGBGOLD

Thanks for your time
Wild horses by rolling stones
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/watchandlisten/play/b07c02f31

AnnD3470LEVEL 62

Reply by AnnD3470GOLD

Brocken Down In Tiny Pieces - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/be874b4b7
I'll Leave This World Loving You - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/bf82a4ffb

thank you for your time

TOMILLERLEVEL 55

Reply by TOMILLERGOLD

“Bring Him Home” http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/b971a0fd3
“Tequila Sunrise” http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/bd70fc7b7
“Don’t Close Your Eyes” http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c29d58c33

Thanks for your time, my friend!
Tom

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Edited reply by socomicefox

"Ace in the Hole" - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/bc922b1eb
"Old Flames" - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c18c8fb4b
"Devil Woman" - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/ae7c1d6f3

Hi,
I would appreciate your opinion!

Regards,
Waynewayne1956

Ace in the hole- Timing was off in this song somewhat. Your vocals was good. This song sounded like it was fun good sing man!

Old flames cant hold a candle to you-What a smooth sing. Like the way you did this sing by dolly parton. Vocals was nice! Timing was great. Sounded like a song a hound dog would love!

Devil Woman! I bet you would sing Johnny Cash really well! This was a great sing Wayne. Your vocals was on point. You was feeling the song. Your timing was good.

You have a unique tone dude. Your voice fit these songs really well! Keep up the good singing. And great job man. You can for sure sing.

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Reply by socomicefox

Thanks for your time
Wild horses by rolling stones
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/watchandlisten/play/b07c02f31WallyGB

Wally. I remember your shaving song ahaha. You dont forget great sings. Dude I like how you did this song. This was actually enjoyable to listen to. Vocals was odd on this song but they worked to make your sing sound good! I think it was more of how much you was into the song. You sing this like you was very drunk but it sounded good! Ahahaa keep up the great singing man!

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Reply by socomicefox

Brocken Down In Tiny Pieces - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/be874b4b7
I'll Leave This World Loving You - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/bf82a4ffb

thank you for your timeAnnD3470

Broken Down In Tiny Pieces- ZzZzZZZzZzZZ Absolutely boring. Yea this song sucked. Awful song choice. Good vocals but this song is just not for ya.

Ill leave this world loving you- Ann you have good vocals! But you sing as if you are really bored. Your timing in this song was good. Again your vocals was good but you just sing as if you are bored. Sing with heart ya know? Sing as if you are on a stage in front of 1000000 ppl and you are putting on the best concert ever. My opinion you are a great singer but you sing as if you are bored.

AnnD3470LEVEL 62

Reply by AnnD3470GOLD

thank you for your honesty I am very nervous when I sing how do I not sound so boring Ha Ha I have been sing on here all most 2 year and I cant get past the nerves HELP please

socomicefoxLEVEL 62

Reply by socomicefox

“Bring Him Home” http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/b971a0fd3
“Tequila Sunrise” http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/bd70fc7b7
“Don’t Close Your Eyes” http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c29d58c33

Thanks for your time, my friend!
TomTOMILLER

Bring him home- Very beautiful sing here. First off sir thank you for serving. You have great vocals. Timing was nice. The emotion you showed in this sing was strong. This was a very professional sing. Well done. Flagged you.

Tequila Sunrise- Love the way you did this song. Was it as great as bring him home? No. But your timing was good your emotion was alright in this sing here. Your vocals sounded on point.

Dont close your eyes- One of my favorite country songs. Tom you did this song your own way and ya know what it sounded good! Timing was off in some parts but your vocals and making this song your own way made up for that. It was kinda like a elvis voice singing this song. Great job man.

AnnD3470LEVEL 62

Reply by AnnD3470GOLD

Brocken Down In Tiny Pieces - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/be874b4b7
I'll Leave This World Loving You - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/bf82a4ffb

thank you for your timeAnnD3470

Broken Down In Tiny Pieces- ZzZzZZZzZzZZ Absolutely boring. Yea this song sucked. Awful song choice. Good vocals but this song is just not for ya.

Ill leave this world loving you- Ann you have good vocals! But you sing as if you are really bored. Your timing in this song was good. Again your vocals was good but you just sing as if you are bored. Sing with heart ya know? Sing as if you are on a stage in front of 1000000 ppl and you are putting on the best concert ever. My opinion you are a great singer but you sing as if you are bored.socomicefox

ok could you recommend a song or two for me to try if you would thank you

TOMILLERLEVEL 55

Reply by TOMILLERGOLD

Thanks again for the listens and comments, my friend!!! Much appreciated!!!
Tom

WallyGBLEVEL 58

Reply by WallyGBGOLD

Thanks again for your time Socomicefox.

jjsingitLEVEL 31

Edited reply by jjsingit

The Twelfth Of Never - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/b67c7d1eb

Thanks for your time. Gimme the truth. I can take it.

wayne1956LEVEL 82

Reply by wayne1956GOLD

"Ace in the Hole" - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/bc922b1eb
"Old Flames" - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c18c8fb4b
"Devil Woman" - http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/ae7c1d6f3

Hi,
I would appreciate your opinion!

Regards,
Waynewayne1956

Ace in the hole- Timing was off in this song somewhat. Your vocals was good. This song sounded like it was fun good sing man!

Old flames cant hold a candle to you-What a smooth sing. Like the way you did this sing by dolly parton. Vocals was nice! Timing was great. Sounded like a song a hound dog would love!

Devil Woman! I bet you would sing Johnny Cash really well! This was a great sing Wayne. Your vocals was on point. You was feeling the song. Your timing was good.

You have a unique tone dude. Your voice fit these songs really well! Keep up the good singing. And great job man. You can for sure sing.socomicefox

Thank you for taking the time to listen and analyze my songs. I want to continue to get better at it and what better way than to hear the truth.

You should hear what these sounded like from me even a year ago. I can hardly stand to listen to them myself.

Thanks Again!
-Wayne

wmccormLEVEL 48

Reply by wmccormGOLD

would you please take a listen,von
Blue Kentucky Girl
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/be9db4323

MsFiToyLEVEL 52

Reply by MsFiToyGOLD

This is a simple one but I'm still curious to hear what you have to say...
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/bb685069b

cctswabsLEVEL 42

Reply by cctswabs

SgtdewLEVEL 48

Reply by SgtdewGOLD

I'll give it a shot.
Will the Circle be Unbroken

http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c070d1669

BrenioLEVEL 52

Reply by BrenioGOLD

Creep ~ Radiohead
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c6bae270f

I have just gotten all new equipment and wasn't sure how it sounds.
Feel free to critique my sound/volume and voice/singing
Thanks

SgtdewLEVEL 48

Reply by SgtdewGOLD

Bren-
ILL give my opinion on your sing.
I really liked the control over this song. Vocals were good.
I only really heard one flat spot toward the end of the sing, but overall felt like you nailed this sing. The feeling really came through.
Very nice bro.

Best Regards,
Scott

BrenioLEVEL 52

Reply by BrenioGOLD

Bren-
ILL give my opinion on your sing.
I really liked the control over this song. Vocals were good.
I only really heard one flat spot toward the end of the sing, but overall felt like you nailed this sing. The feeling really came through.
Very nice bro.

Best Regards,
ScottSgtdew

Thanks for the feedback. Being my first recording in 4 years I wasn't sure how it sounded.

lamonttriesLEVEL 28

Reply by lamonttriesGOLD

lamonttriesLEVEL 28

Reply by lamonttriesGOLD

SgtdewLEVEL 48

Edited reply by SgtdewGOLD

Lamonttries - Rodney, the host of this post hasn't been here for awhile. If you want my honest opinion, Ill give it to you, but I'm no pro either. Just willing to tell you my thoughts.
My opinion is that you actually have a really great soulful voice. I love that and it made listening to you really easy. Here's my honest critique. Your pitch, voice and timing are all great, but your control in certain parts kinda drifts here and there. I think you could be a better singer than you are now by watching this. Other than that, You sing your butt off!
Enjoyed the listen.
Scott

MasquaradeLEVEL 69

Reply by MasquaradeCHAT-ADMIN

Honest opinions appreciated

Indigo Girls - Power Of Two
http://www.singsnap.com/karaoke/r/c6a0f20c3

  Next >>